Should my kids share a room?

January 13, 2012
By

It’s music to my hubby’s ears.

“Me and Blake want to share a room,” says Brodie.

“Can we have a bunkbed?”

Now I know what Mr G is thinking….

Study.

With both boys in one bedroom, he can reclaim a room for his computer and all his nerdy nick nacks (well I ask you, who else has a collection of dalek figures from Dr Who?)

I’m not so sure.

“Blake might wake you up a bit earlier in the morning,” I warn my eldest.

He shrugs that he’s not bothered.

“And you’d have to go straight to bed at bedtime – no playing or messing around in your room if you’re sharing.”

He nods again.

“I love Blake. I don’t mind.”

Part of me wonders if he’ll love his three-year-old brother when he’s poking him in the face at 6am.

Brodie is almost six, and generally goes to bed at 8pm (or at least he goes to his bedroom and plays for half an hour, before dropping off) then sleeps through to 8am.

Blake is a whole different story. His bedtime is anywhere between 7 and 7.30pm – with lots of appearances at the top of the landing, crying and asking for extra cuddles/drinks/teddies.

He calls out in the night at least twice – generally just needing to be tucked back in, given a drink, or cuddled out of a bad dream.

And then he’s up anytime from 7am.

Not a huge chasm between the two of them.

But with Brodie in school now, I’m aware he needs his rest, and wonder if sharing will mean less sleep.

On the other hand, Blake might be more settled, knowing his big brother is within reach. The bad dreams and fear of monsters in his room could disappear.

They have shared a room on holiday with few problems (Blake still wakes in the night, but his brother snores through the entire thing).

They’re ready for a bed upgrade, as Blake’s legs are just about poking out of the end of the toddler bed.

And I love the range of bunkbeds on offer just now (a shopping spree beckons).

But will I be making a mistake? Are we doing this just for the extra space?

We’ve taught our boys to share everything.

But is this a step too far?

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...

Tags: , , , ,

  • http://www.susankmann.com Susan Mann

    My boys are about the same age apart from yours. My oldest has just turned 5 and my youngest is about to turn 3. My youngest sleeps pretty much through the night with the occasional shout out and the oldest wakes for the toilet during the night. The have shared a room since the little one was 1 year old and the oldest just turned 3. My oldest didn’t sleep well on his own and was always crying out. As soon as we put his brother in with him he has slept so much better. We don’t have that big an issue of them waking each other up during the night sometimes in the morning is a different issue but nothing major. The moved onto bunk beds last year. Ones with quite high side especially on the top bunk and they love it. The best thing I ever did for them. They still love sharing a room. Not sure they will forever but so far so good and the bunk beds have not been an issue in the slightest. We got them ones that are like a big football bus. Its great. I say go for it. x

    • http://www.mummycentral.com Donna@MummyCentral

      Thanks Susan. I was paranoid about them waking each other up when Blake was a baby. Know they’ll want their own space again when they’re teenagers. But if sharing for 5/6 years keeps them happy (and hubby too) then I think it’s worth a try. I am secretly hoping Blake’s sleeping will improve a little when he’s got big bro there to calm him.
      Where did you get your bunkbeds? Looks like I’m in for a shopping trip

  • http://boorootiggertoo.blogspot.com/ Boo Roo and Tigger Too

    Can’t relate to the sharing a room issue but I have just purchased bunkbeds for Roo, I chose the ‘Sarah’ bunk beds in white as we bought her white furniture last year. Try http://www.bedworld.net x

    • http://www.mummycentral.com Donna@MummyCentral

      Thanks honey. I’ll take a look x

  • http://www.TheBoyandMe.co.uk TheBoyandMe

    I shared with my sister and it was a huge mistake. However, we’re very different people and also females. I reckon the boys could like it and you should give it a try.

    • http://www.mummycentral.com Donna@MummyCentral

      Know what you mean. If I had two girls, I probably wouldn’t consider this.
      We are planning on putting a sofa bed into Brodie’s old room, so if it all goes wrong he could move back in and we could gradually make it his bedroom again.

  • http://www.actuallymummy.co.uk Actually Mummy…

    I think you may be surprised. In an ideal world he will sleep through any interruptions, and maybe even keep his little brother quiet playing after early wake-ups while you snooze. Plus, he may just provide the company to stop the night interruptions. Of course it could go wrong, but let’s look on the bright side! ;)

    • http://www.mummycentral.com Donna@MummyCentral

      It’s a bit of a social experiment isn’t it? I’m not sure if the boys are thinking beyond the excitement of having bunkbeds. We’ll see what happens (I’ll probably blog about it).

  • Feejaybee

    It’s interesting that sometimes sharing a room is viewed as a strange thing. It is actually overwhelming normal for people to sleep in the same room (or bed) as another family member. How quickly Western society has adopted separate rooms for each child.

    In our house, with five kids, room-sharing is normality. We have two girls (17 and 10) who have been in the same room for about seven years. They have always got on well, but I think that the larger age gap helps. Our younger boys (12 and 9) have also shared for a long time, and certainly it is a great help for the youngest who tends to be fearful. When the 12-year-old is away, the younger one finds it very lonely.

    There are lots of benefits for kids in terms of bonding with their siblings while sharing a room.

    • http://www.mummycentral.com/ Donna@MummyCentral

      Thanks for the feedback honey. I think youngest being a bad sleeper has made me nervous to do this. But the boys are desperate to be together and I think you’re right. They will bond more and (possibly) the little one will feel more secure.

Make Your Mum Feel Special This Mothers Day

As featured on GMTV, Breastlight is a device that assists women in their early detection of breast cancer.

Archives

Categories

BritMums - All the Cool Blogs... and me

Switch to our mobile site